Legal Blogs

What Happens When a California Corporation’s Board of Directors Is Deadlocked?

What Happens When a California Corporation's Board of Directors Is Deadlocked?Disagreements among corporate directors are common, particularly in closely held corporations where ownership is divided equally between two shareholders or groups of shareholders. But what happens when the directors cannot agree on important business decisions and the corporation becomes paralyzed?

For example, consider a corporation with four directors. Two directors want to remove the company’s president, while the other two oppose the removal. The same directors disagree about the company’s finances, management, and future direction. Neither side has enough votes to take action.

When this happens, California law provides a solution.

Appointment of a Provisional Director Under California Law

California Corporations Code section 308 allows the Superior Court to appoint a provisional director when a corporation has an even number of directors who are equally divided and cannot agree on the management of the corporation’s affairs. The deadlock must prevent the corporation from conducting its business to advantage or create a danger that its property or business will be impaired or lost.

A petition seeking appointment of a provisional director may be filed by any director or by shareholders holding at least one-third of the corporation’s voting power.

The provisional director is an independent individual appointed by the court who has the same voting rights and powers as the other directors. For example, in a corporation with four directors divided two against two, the provisional director effectively becomes a fifth director who can cast the deciding vote.

The provisional director must be impartial and cannot be a shareholder or creditor of the corporation. The director’s responsibility is to exercise independent judgment in the corporation’s best interests, not to favor either side of the dispute.

Other Ways to Resolve a Corporate Deadlock

Court intervention is not always necessary. Depending on the circumstances, the parties may resolve their differences through negotiation, mediation, a shareholder buyout, or the voluntary appointment of an additional director.

In more serious situations, California Corporations Code section 1800 permits shareholders to seek involuntary dissolution of a corporation based on certain types of deadlock. However, dissolution is a drastic remedy that can destroy the value of an otherwise successful business.

For that reason, appointing a provisional director can be an effective way to break the deadlock while preserving the corporation’s operations and value.

Experienced Orange County Corporate Litigation Attorneys

At Brown & Charbonneau, LLP, we have extensive experience representing shareholders, directors, and corporations in disputes involving corporate control, breaches of fiduciary duty, and management deadlocks.

When disagreements among directors threaten a corporation’s ability to operate, it is important to understand the available legal remedies before the dispute causes significant damage to the business.

Contact Brown & Charbonneau, LLP to discuss your options for resolving a corporate board deadlock.

Related reading: Should Business Owners Agree to Binding Arbitration or Take Their Chances in Court? | Can You Recover Attorney’s Fees Under an Expired Contract in California? | Shareholder Disputes