Can We Collect Our Attorneys Fees If We Win Our Case?
Recovery of Attorney’s Fees in Contract and Other Business Disputes
Under the “American Rule” each party to a lawsuit is responsible for their own attorney’s fees. One of the largest exceptions to the American Rule is where attorney’s fees are authorized by contract. California Civil Code Section 1717 functions to make “one-sided” attorney fee provisions reciprocal. Therefore, if a prevailing Plaintiff in a contract case can recover its attorney’s fees, so can a prevailing defendant.
In practice, however, when a Defendant can receive attorney’s fees under Section 1717 is not always so clear. Ultimately whether a Defendant can recover its attorney’s fees under section 1717 depends on the pleadings, the evidence produced at trial, and the nature of the defense.
When a Defendant Can Recover Attorney Fees
A defendant can receive attorney fees under section 1717 if they prevail in a breach of contract action, and there is no dispute that the contract contains an attorney fee provision. The most common example of this is where the parties agree that a contract with an attorney fee provision exists, and only dispute whether or not the contract was breached.
Further, Civil Code Section 1717 allows a defendant to recover attorney’s fees in a lawsuit on a contract even where the defendant prevails by proving that no contract exists. Therefore, if the evidence at trial shows that the alleged contract did have an attorney fee provision, but the defendant prevails by proving the contract didn’t exist or was otherwise invalid, it may recovery its attorney’s fees.
When a Defendant Cannot Recover Attorney’s Fees
A defendant cannot recover attorney’s fees under section 1717 if there is no attorney fee provision in the contract. This is true even where the Plaintiff claims entitlement to attorney’s fees in its complaint. Thus, if the evidence at trial shows that there was no attorney fee provision in the contract, neither party can recover their fees even if the Complaint says otherwise.
When Recovering Attorney’s Fees is Less Obvious
What happens if the Plaintiff alleges in its Complaint that the Defendant breached a contract with an attorney’s fee provision, and that attorney’s fee provision is later called into question?
In this situation a party claiming fees under section 1717 must establish that the opposing party actually would have been entitled to receive fees if they had been the prevailing party. Courts have been clear that this does not require a second “mini-trial” on the issue of attorney fees. Rather, if a Plaintiff pleads a right to attorney’s fees, attempts to prove they are entitled to attorney’s fees, and loses, a Defendant can recover their fees.
Getting Legal Help
Brown & Charbonneau, LLP represents individuals as well as large and small companies in cases involving all forms of contract and business disputes. If you are involved in a contract dispute or a business dispute, or would like to learn about your rights and how to protect them, we can provide you with the information you need. Contact us or call today at 714-505-3000 to schedule a consultation and learn more about how we can help you.
Brown & Charbonneau, LLP is a top-rated business litigation, corporate, real estate and family law firm in Irvine, California. We are honored to be named by Best’s Lawyers® as one of the Top Law Firms in the US, including the specialty area of commercial litigation. As an AV-rated law firm, we are proud of our 10.0 Superb Client Rating from Avvo. Our top-reviewed Southern California attorneys have also earned specializations from the State Bar of California, as Certified Trial Specialists, and are included amongst the elite attorneys to be named Super Lawyers®.
Should you have any other issues involving any of the below areas of practice, please feel free to contact us.
- General Business & Corporate
- Business Litigation & Contract Disputes
- Civil Litigation
- Partnership & Shareholder Disputes
- Fraud Claims
- Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claims
- Real Estate & Construction Disputes
- Trade Secrets, Non-Competes & Unfair Competition
- Employment Disputes
- Personal Injury & Elder Abuse Cases
- Trial Specialist
- Family Law
Our website is full of valuable information and resources. Our goal is to provide as much information as possible to assist all our clients in making fully informed decisions. Just click any area of interest.
Brown & Charbonneau, LLP publications should not be construed as legal advice on any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general information purposes only and may not be quoted or referred to in any other publication or proceeding without the prior written consent of the Firm, to be given or withheld at our discretion. To request reprint permission for any of our publications, please use our “Contact Us” form, which can be found on our website at www.bc-llp.com. The mailing of this publication is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. The views set forth herein are the personal views of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Firm.